If you are a subscriber to the Urban Agriculture Magazine and would like to keep your subscription, renew your subscription here.
If you are not yet subscribed to the Urban Agriculture Magazine but would like to become a subscriber, subscribe here.
Give us your opinion!!!
What do you think of the UA-Magazine? We have sent a survey to all subscribers with the UA-Magazine no 18, but you can also fill out the questionnaire here. We will use your ideas and comments to improve the Magazine. We appreciate your cooperation: thank you!!
The Urban Agriculture Magazine is an initiative under the RUAF Programme. It functions as a platform for exchange and discussion of grounded information on urban agriculture: research results, project experiences, and critical analyses of conventional and innovative policies on urban agriculture. The Urban Agriculture Magazine is published on this website twice a year. Articles are presented in PDF (including illustrations and graphics). The Magazine is available in several languages.
We invite you to contribute to the Urban Agriculture Magazine with an article, a description of best (or bad) practices, photos and information on interesting publications, web sites, and forthcoming events. An article contribution should give a clear description of the urban aspects and policy implications of your experiences and include recommendations for local policy makers and planners.
Articles should be written in such a way that those working with farmers could readily understand them. We would like to receive articles of up to 2,500 words long (This is about 5-6 pages A4). Articles should preferably be accompanied by illustrations, good quality photos and references. We appreciate the availability of a good abstract. Articles are examined for selection by the editorial team consisting of the RUAF editor and the external scientific advisor/co-editor. Click here for more information on the following magazine. Contributions can be sent to: ruaf@etcnl.nl
References to agriculture in the city go back a long time in history. Literature references on agriculture in the city and on urban agriculture are more recent. Growing cities and populations are one of the big challenges of the future. The importance of urban agriculture in sustainable urban development is growing, and recognition grows.
This maiden issue of the UA Magazine has sought to give a broad picture of urban agriculture, both thematic and background of cases. Most of the articles further show the importance of urban agriculture, as a tradition, as a strategy of improving access to food, and/or as a response to crises. Subsequently, the need to incorporate urban agriculture in urban planning and policies is highlighted.
Future issues of the UA Magazine will focus on a specific theme.
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
Growing cities and urban populations are some of the big challenges of the future. The importance of urban agriculture in sustainable urban development is growing. As recognition grows, more people are becoming involved in the issue. Many newsletters and magazines have devoted issues to the subject in recent years, including GATE, Urban Age, African Urban Quarterly, and the LEISA Newsletter, and there have been many workshops and conferences on the subject.
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
This article is a part of a longer article by Luc Mougeot of IDRC from Growing Cities, Growing Food (Bakker et al., 2000). In this excerpt, the author takes the need for conceptual maturity of urban agriculture as a starting point to show the various dimensions of urban agriculture and to claim its firm position in the urban system.
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
The authors discuss why people get involved in urban agriculture. The article is based on information extracted from 20 city case studies on urban agriculture worldwide and additionally draws from experiences of the Urban Vegetable Promotion Project in Dar Es Salaam (Tanzania). They argue that local authorities have to take their responsibilities in securing urban food security and to create an impact on urban poverty alleviation.
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
Jac Smit of TUAN (The Urban Agriculture Network, based in the USA) argues that bringing back agriculture, forestry, aquaculture and livestock rearing to the human settlement is a key component in reducing the negative ecological footprint of cities that is 50 to 125 times the area of the city itself. He illustrates this with a number of interesting examples.
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
The major objective of the International workshop in Havana, Cuba was: 'to move urban agriculture beyond the daily reality of urban farmers to the agenda of policy-makers'. In synthesising that conference, the authors review the variety of conditions that facilitate the growth of UA, and, secondly, discuss a range of policy options to selectively support the development of sustainable urban food production systems. This article is an abridged version of article you can find in Growing Cities, Growing Food (Bakker et al., 2000).
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
Government services concerned with livestock production for urban populations have given most attention to large-scale livestock rearing in the urban periphery. Small-scale rearing of animals by families living inside the cities is usually ignored and often forbidden. However, such urban livestock keeping is much more widespread than most city authorities would care to admit. Ann Waters-Bayer discusses the growth in urban livestock keeping in recent years, classifies various types of urban livestock systems, outlines functions of livestock, and indicates some of the problems caused by these systems.
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
The importance of home gardens, the small areas of cultivated land immediately surrounding a home or a homestead, is often underestimated despite its vital contribution to meeting various household-needs, especially for the poor families in developing countries. The authors explore the importance of homegardens in the Philippines and give the findings of the programme, Users' Perspectives with Agricultural Research and Development (UPWARD).
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
Urban forestry programmes and projects need longer time to show results. Trees are long-term products and to make an urban forestry programme a success, the project partners need to keep a constant dialogue and a long-term commitment to make it happen. Liliana Marulanda illustrates this in a description of the Ahmedabad Green Partnership Project, which is an effort between the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC) and the Private Sector towards increasing the green cover and improving the environmental quality of Ahmedabad, India.
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
The St. Petersburg Downtown Gardening Club is one of the six Eastern European organizations active in SWAPUA, SWAPUA stands for 'Soil and Water Management in Agricultural Production in Urban Areas in CEE/NIS Countries'. In this contribution, Oleg Moldakov from the St. Petersburg Downtown Gardening Club shows that the urban gardening movement in St. Petersburg has a long-standing history, both as a strategy to overcome shortcomings in food availability and for income improvement.
In: UA Magazine 1 - Maiden issue
Martin Bourque and Kristina Canizares from Food First, describe the impact of urban agriculture in Havana on availability and cost of fresh produce. The rise of urban agriculture was a clear response on the crisis of the early 1990s, and was stimulated by Government programmes and by the use of appropriate technologies.
The UA-Magazine is published by the Resource Centre for Urban Agriculture (RUAF), a Programme executed by ETC Netherlands and financed by DGIS, The Netherlands and IDRC, Canada. It is published 3 times a year. In the future the UA-Magazine will also be published in French and Spanish, and distributed through regional institutions.
This Issue has been compiled by Henk de Zeeuw (guest editor) and René van Veenhuizen (responsible editor).
Except for the article of Ahmedabad (photos by L. Marulanda), photos available at RUAF have been used, of the following sources: C. Schilter (Togo), B. Mbiba (Zimbabwe), T. Pinzas (Peru), P. Jacobi (Tanzania), F. Nunan (India), L.M. Sanchez (México), M. Amar-Klemesu (Ghana), PUVPP Project (Phillippines), Ciudad de Havana (Cuba).
![]()
The first issue of the Urban Agriculture Magazine presented articles covering the broad spectrum of urban agriculture. This second issue focuses on a specific topic: Urban Livestock, and this is how the Urban Agriculture Magazine will appear from now on. It will be published three times a year, each time covering a specific topic.
This issue came out a bit later than planned. The number of articles submitted was high, and we certainly hope we will receive the same kind of enthusiasm for the next issues. We offer you 16 articles in this issue. It was decided to publish almost all of the submitted articles, because the issue of urban livestock appeared to cover many different aspects, and only by taking all these contributions together we felt the issue was adequately dealt with. In forthcoming issues we will continue to try to keep the amount of articles to about 10, not going over the 40 pages in the paper version of the Urban Agriculture Magazine.
The appearance of the Urban Agriculture Magazine has been received very positively, and various encouraging reactions on the first issue have been sent to us. We have put the Editorial Board in place, in which persons of different organisations take a seat, including the Regional Focal Points on Urban Agriculture. These organisations will play a major role in the further development and regionalisation of the UA Magazine in the near future. In the next issue you will receive more information on this.
The subscription policy of the UA Magazine is under discussion with the RUAF Focal Points and the Editorial Board, but it is certain that the hardcopy edition will cost you about 15 US$ per year. Of course, the UA Magazine will remain available for free on RUAF's web site.
Guest editors for this issue were Azage Tegegne from ILRI in Addis Adeba, Ethiopia and Hans Schiere, from IAC and Wageningen University, The Netherlands. A considerable input was also received from the Urban Livestock group of ETC: Ann Waters Bayer, Katrien van 't Hooft, Sheila Oparachoa and Willem van Weperen. A great thanks to them all.
The Editor.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
The cobblestones of the streets in the old city of Pompeii near Rome are scarred by the wheels of wagons that used to be drawn by horses and/or oxen, for carrying goods or for supplying the military. The covered bridge in Florence is now the home of goldsmiths and jewellers who replaced butchers and fish traders, supposedly because a 'Medici' queen complained of the smell.
(A. Scappini, pers. communication 2000)
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
For two centuries after the Dutch settlement of New Amsterdam agriculture on Manhattan Island remained not all that dissimilar from farming elsewhere in northern North America. Over the years farm families engaged in both commercial and subsistence production, raising livestock, garden and field crops. They gladly sold surpluses when they existed, but always sought to provide for domestic needs first.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
Urban livestock agriculture (ULA) in the USA is a constructive, yet largely unknown, underground, and unevenly regulated activity. Livestock encompasses multiple meanings for practitioners in the urban environments: economic buttress, tradition, cultural and/or religious endurance, and community cohesiveness. Research on and policy development for urban livestock (as for community food security generally) is lacking and needed. However, because livestock in the city is kept under diverse legal, illegal, and quasi-legal conditions, and because practitioners tend not to be part of the dominant culture, care must be taken to raise the issues under circumstances of support. In this article it is argued that issues of invisibility, distrust, and/or animosity between regulators and practitioners of urban livestock are founded more in the lack of attention paid by policy makers to food systems and food security generally, than in insurmountable challenges of urban livestock as a positive urban land use.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
A review of dairies and pig-keeping in the twin-city of Hubli-Dharwad, in the State of Karnataka, illustrates the role of livestock in household livelihood strategies in Indian cities. Small urban dairies and roaming pigs are a common sight in Hubli-Dharwad and make an important contribution to household livelihoods and urban food supplies. However, the future of livestock keeping in urban centres can be questioned, given public concerns at city and national level and recent moves by city authorities to evict pigs.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
In the streets of urban India, many cows can be seen scavenging around. At first glance it may appear as though the cattle are an undisputed part of city life, but the case of Delhi shows that the issue is surrounded by controversy. The persistence of dairy farming in the city is related to how villages and their people become urbanised. Since 1951, about 140 villages have become completely incorporated into the city of Delhi (Census of India, 1991). Caste-specific economic traditions and constraints cause certain households to continue dairy farming despite the spatial constraints.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
The Beja are a confederation of tribes united by a common language, TuBedawiye, and a common segmentary structure, each of which is linked to a common ownership and use of land. The three main tribes are the Amar'ar/Atmaan, the Bishariyyn and the Hadendowa, who mostly live in North-eastern Sudan between the Egyptian and the Eritrean borders, and all speak similar versions of TuBedawiye. This article describes the migration of Beja pastoralist labour to Port Sudan from Halaib Province (NE Sudan). It reviews the different livestock holdings that the Beja have in town and shows that, although most urban-based pastoralists live in great poverty, some manage to successfully exploit urban opportunities whilst continuing to engage in rural-based livelihood strategies.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
The main agricultural cities of Senegal are located in the Niayes Zone. Production in this zone accounts for more than two thirds of the total horticultural production, and urban livestock is also well represented. Livestock keeping is well integrated into the production systems, in the form of waste recycling and animal traction. Considerable efforts are being made to restructure the production system in order to meet increasing demand for animal products. An exploratory study of the main agricultural systems in the Niayes Zone indicated that there is great diversity in farm products (fruit and vegetables as well as livestock) and also potential for further development. The main constraints to further development are the land tenure system, deterioration of natural resources, lack of organisation of farmers and minimal access to credit.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
In a survey done in 1999, basic information was collected on urban farming practices in Nakuru, Kenya. The main aim was to obtain a general overview of urban agriculture in this town for the local authorities in the context of their town planning exercises. Part of the survey covered several aspects of livestock keeping.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
In this article a systems approach is used to describe urban and peri-urban dairy production systems in Addis Ababa. These urban and peri-urban dairy production systems evolved to satisfy the increasing demand for milk in urban centres as a consequence of increasing urbanisation, rising per capita income and increasing cost of imported milk and milk products. They contribute to overall development through income and employment generation, food security, asset accumulation, poverty alleviation and improving human nutrition and health.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
Livestock production is a vital part of urban and peri-urban agriculture (UPA) in Kumasi, where many crop farmers benefit from cheap poultry manure available in large quantities. However, with increasing competition for this resource, the manure is seldom stored long enough to prevent the contamination of food and water with pathogens. While the actual incidence of disease related to this contamination has not yet been assessed, interventions to prevent the spread of infection should focus first of all on the consumer household. Farmers' access to clean irrigation water is another important step but only makes sense if farmers' own practices do not contribute to water pollution.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
Kumasi is Ghana's second largest city after Accra and is the capital of the Ashanti Region. Kumasi is located in the south-central part of the country 100 miles inland from the coast and the Kumasi Metropolitan Assembly (KMA) is responsible for a population of some 700,000 to 1 million people. The survey reported here was undertaken as an MSc project by the senior author, in 1999 with the aim of characterising urban livestock keeping in Kumasi and identifying the problems encountered by livestock keepers.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
At the end of the 19th century, Sansón Carrasco (nom de plume of Daniel Muñoz, 1849-1930), reported on pigs being bred with household wastes. His chronicles are still valid today. For instance, in his article "Trash" (1883), he writes:
"...and in the depressions, and on the beach, pigs and more pigs, and always pigs everywhere you look, some of them feeding, some stretched out without a care in the world, others grunting as they get a glimpse of me, as if upset by my intrusion in their domain..."
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
Zoonoses have been defined by WHO (1959) as 'Those disease and infections (the agents of) which are naturally transmitted between (other) vertebrate animals and man'. Recently the concept has been enlarged with the following proposal: 'Any detriment to the health and/or quality of human life deriving from relationships with (other) vertebrate or edible or toxic invertebrate animals', Mantovani 2000).
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
Cysticercosis is one of the most dangerous diseases caused by a parasite that passes from animals to human beings. It is most prevalent in the rural areas of developing countries, from where it can become a threat in urban areas too. Cysticercosis is closely related to economic standards, culture and aspects of hygiene. Latin America, non-Islamic parts of Africa and South East Asia and especially India face major problems with this disease. In this article the author describes cysticercosis that originates from pigs (Cysticercosis cellulosae) in Bolivia, South America.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
Rosario City in the province of Santa Fe, Argentina is an urban centre of more than 1,200,000 inhabitants. Over 20% of the population live in conditions of extreme poverty. Unemployment and marginality leads them to live in the marginal areas, without adequate sanitary services and under limited social and economic conditions. There are many examples of social welfare interventions, which can help to alleviate these conditions of dire poverty.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
Pig-raising in urban areas has become important in meeting the growing pork demand. The main constraints to using sweet potato vines as pig feed are labour and storage. Regardless of how they are fed to the animals, the vines must first be chopped into small pieces, a daunting and time-consuming task, mainly undertaken by women. If the vines are fed fresh, the women must allocate time each day for this task, even during the busy field season. Silage offers a potential alternative and overcomes both main constraints.
In: UA Magazine 2 - Livestock in and around cities
A model for integrated higher education for training veterinary medical-animal husbandry students is discussed. In this model, students analyse local seasonal foodstuffs and immunisation and parasitism, while learning about marginal livestock producer needs. Both the University and the livestock producing families benefit. The former because it uses local resources, and the latter because they increase their knowledge, and use of foodstuffs, and reduce parasitism and, presumably, public health problems too.
The UA-Magazine is published by the Resource Centre for Urban Agriculture (RUAF), a Programme executed by ETC Netherlands and financed by DGIS, The Netherlands and IDRC, Canada. It is published 3 times a year. In future, the UA Magazine will be published in French and Spanish, and distributed, possibly in separate editions, through regional networks.
This issue has been compiled by René van Veenhuizen (responsible editor), with Hans Schiere, WAU, The Netherlands and Azage Tegegne, of ILRI, Ethiopia (guest editors). Further inputs have been received by Willem van Weperen, Sheila Oparachoa, Katrien van ?t Hooft and Ann Waters-Bayer of ETC-Urban Livestock.
![]()
Urban agriculture is practised to a substantial degree in many cities in the world. In discussions on a sustainable development of urban agriculture the positive and negative relationships play an important role, whether based on facts or on prejudice. Health is a major issue in this. There is indeed an obvious relationship between urban agriculture on the one hand, and the health and environmental conditions of the urban population on the other. This third issue of the UA-Magazine focuses on the relationship between urban agriculture and health.
Once again, the number of articles submitted to the magazine was high. We offer you ten articles on a diversity of topics surrounding the theme; food security, food policies, use of waste and wastewater and zoonoses. Unfortunately, a contribution on food security and nutrition was withdrawn at the latest moment. In order to fit into the magazine, some articles had to be cut down from the original. Only two- or three-page articles (1,700-2,500 words) are placed in the hard copy of the UA-Magazine. The RUAF website provides more room for longer articles, while also contributions that could not be included in this hard copy issue are shown on www.ruaf.org.
The guest editor for this issue was Karen Lock, from the European Centre on the Health of Societies in Transition, at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. Karen was also involved in the Electronic Conference, on which she reports together with Henk de Zeeuw. Further support was received from Marianne Lindner, from the ETC Health Group, who recently finished an analysis of key issues in urban health and health-care in developing countries.
Starting in 2001, the UA-Magazine is translated into French and Spanish, and is distributed through the RUAF Regional Focal Points in Asia, Africa and Latin America. This makes the readership substantially higher than the originally registered readers at RUAF in Leusden. At the moment we send the UA-Magazine to about 4,000 addresses.
You are invited to contribute to future issues of the UA-Magazine. Firstly, please note the call for contributions to the next two issues, at the end of this magazine. Secondly, any suggestions you might have for topics for 2002 are welcome. Issues that are thus far being considered for 2002 are:
Submitted articles should be written in such a way that those working with farmers would readily be able to understand them. Articles would ideally be up to 2,500 words in length, and preferably accompanied by illustrations (digital if possible), references and a good abstract. Articles will be examined for selection by the editorial team consisting of the responsible editor and the external scientific advisor/co-editor.
Looking forward to hearing from you.
The Editor.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
Urban agriculture can have both negative and positive effects on the health and environmental conditions of the urban population. Previous reviews or studies of health issues have tended to highlight the health risks of urban and periurban agriculture (e.g. Birley and Lock 1999). This has served to reinforce the perceptions of many governments and municipal authorities that urban agriculture is a (marginal) activity that has substantial health risks and should not be supported.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
This article focuses on the discussion from the UPA, Health and Environment session of the E-conference. The effects of UPA on the environment were also discussed but will not be included here.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
Food production and its retail sales are increasingly perceived to be presenting risks to society in Europe. Consumers are concerned, and have lost trust and confidence in their food supply. Policies are therefore needed to limit the risks and to promote the assets of different means of food production and distribution, as well as to restore consumer confidence.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
During the last several decades, a considerable investment of financial resources has been directed towards the development of curative drugs and vaccines against malaria, and to the evaluation of chemical insecticides for mosquito control. Historically, the agricultural dimension has received little attention from the research community, despite its importance as a contributory factor to malaria transmission risks and its inherent opportunities for paradoxically minimising such risks. The incorporation of a relevant health component in agricultural research could contribute to the identification of opportunities for minimising malaria risks through agriculturally-based interventions, both in rural and in urban and periurban settings. The CGIAR system-wide initiative on malaria and agriculture (SIMA) co-ordinated by IWMI (see Networking Section in this issue) has taken up this challenge.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
The safety of food produced in urban agriculture depends on a number of factors, including the history of persistent toxic chemicals applied to an area. Using the application of organochlorine pesticides in Perth, Western Australia as a case study, this article examines the problems that can arise when urban agriculture is scattered throughout a metropolitan area, and carried out by people who often have little detailed knowledge of how land in the area has historically been treated, and therefore what kinds of soil contamination might be present. The article concludes with recommendations for health and local government workers, which could help to ensure that households are aware of the potential health risks associated with food production in urban areas, and are able to act to minimise those risks.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
Manila typifies the best and the worst of Asian cities. Affluent residential areas with functional sewerage and regular waste collection border squalid areas of cardboard shacks with no amenities. High-rise office and apartment buildings in the municipality of Makati stand in contrast to the squatter areas in Taguig, Muntinlupa, and Mandaluyong.The collapse of the Payatas garbage dump in August 2000 and the deaths of at least 220 squatters who lived at the dump site to scavenge discarded refuse are symptomatic of urban blight and poverty which threaten civility, governance and life itself.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
Zoonoses are infections naturally transmitted between vertebrate animals and humans, either directly or indirectly through the consumption of contaminated foods. Traditional zoonotic diseases for which effective control measures and cures are available in affluent countries, are still a cause of morbidity and mortality in humans and animals in developing countries (Wastling et al. 1999, Cosivi et al. 1995). Increasing urbanisation, the growth of livestock production in close proximity to humans, the rising rate of HIV, inadequate hygienic practices, and cultural customs and beliefs exacerbate the transmission, persistence and impact of zoonotic diseases in these regions.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
Farming fish in ponds fertilised with urban wastewater or sewage is not widespread although it does benefit millions of people, particularly in China, India and Vietnam. It provides food and employment, particularly for the poor, and more general environmental benefits such as low-cost wastewater treatment, stormwater drainage and provision of green areas or "lungs" which improve the health and well-being of urban residents.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
Whereas health concerns received little attention at the beginning of the thrust to promote urban and periurban agriculture in the past five years, progress has been made in articulating the health issues in developing countries. This paper comments further on one aspect related to the issue of health and urban agriculture: the risks of urban organic solid waste re-use. The focus is the relation of health risk management to informal or community-based practices, which are seen as a major challenge for agriculture in the city. Because the capacity of governments to intervene is currently limited, gradual progress in self-regulation or self-limitation of risks is necessary. International projects and experts can assist in developing appropriate standards, research and practical measures.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
In many areas of the world, urban agriculture depends on water supplies for irrigation. Water is often extracted from rivers, and these may be contaminated with wastewater, discharged into the river with little or no prior treatment. In some areas, untreated wastewater is used for irrigation directly. Use of both can increase the risk of gastro-intestinal diseases for farm workers and their families, and for the consumers of the crops. Policy makers and farmers need to know what quality of water they can use, and what forms of wastewater treatment (or other health protection measures) can be employed. As the water available for irrigation often does not meet national standards or international guidelines for wastewater reuse, this poses a challenge to the safe development of urban agriculture.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
Though seemingly trivial, this statement is pertinent as we realise how difficult it is to satisfy all water needs, encompassing domestic needs, agricultural activities, residential and recreational needs. This competition is especially tough in dry climates of the Sahelian zone, such as in Burkina Faso, Mauretania and Senegal Ã? the three countries on which we are focusing our attention. Here, water is the major stumbling block to developing agricultural activities, and domestic needs win out over agricultural activities in the competition for water.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
In Africa, more than one-third of the population already lives in urban cities, and over the next 25 years, the rapid urbanisation of Africa could lead to increasing food insecurity in the cities. In Ghana, the urban population is growing at an estimated annual rate of 4.1% compared with the overall population growth of 3%. Among major urban problems are those related to unemployment and under-employment, as well as high food prices especially due to the high costs of marketing food products. The growing demand for fresh and perishable agricultural produce in the major cities is driving the development of peri-urban agriculture. This demand is not seasonal, necessitating year-round production, heavily dependent on irrigation.
In: UA Magazine 3 - Health aspects of urban agriculture
Ecological sanitation, through urine diversion, may contribute to food security, less pollution, better resource management of water, nutrients and soil. It is likely that it can also contribute to health and well-being in two direct ways: less transmission of disease, by killing pathogens at the source, and increased food security, by increasing nutrient intake. It is far more feasible financially and ecologically than conventional approaches, not only by reducing inputs into the system, but increasing savings throughout urban economies. It results in decentralised systems, empowering people, providing for local livelihoods, and enhancing community cohesion. It can be made safer than conventional sanitation approaches and less polluting, reducing urban expenditures for health care and environmental clean-up as well as potentially increasing tourism dollars.
The UA-Magazine is published by the Resource Centre for Urban Agriculture (RUAF), a Programme executed by ETC Netherlands and financed by DGIS, The Netherlands and IDRC, Canada. It is published 3 times a year. The UA Magazine is translated into French and Spanish, and distributed in separate editions through regional networks.
This issue has been compiled by René van Veenhuizen (Responsible Editor), together with Karen Lock (Guest Editor). Inputs have been received by Marianne Lindner of ETC-Crystal.
![]()
In regions of the world characterised by economic collapse, such as those in East and Southern Africa, the last decade has witnessed a tremendous increase in total city area under informal urban food production. Associated with this has been an unprecedented increase in worldwide attention to urban agriculture. Yet, the overall picture shows that formal recognition and integration of urban agriculture into urban planning and city development has hardly changed, save for a reduction in prohibitive or anti-urban agriculture interventions.
This issue deals with the integration of urban agriculture into city planning.
Again, the amount of articles submitted to the magazine was very high, for which we thank you. It was decided to accept quite a lot of these articles, since the wealth of experiences is illustrated and the broad topic could only be covered sufficiently this way. The guest editor for this issue was Beacon Mbiba from Zimbabwe, Co-ordinator of PeriNET (Peri-Urban Transformations Research Network), South Bank University, London, UK. Further input was received from Axel Drescher, from the University of Freiburg, Germany. The latter reports on the FAO-ETC E-Conference session on Planning (held in September 2000) in this issue. We offer you sixteen articles on a diversity of topics surrounding the theme; Integration of Urban Agriculture into Urban Planning. Articles cover all regions again, although West-Africa is not represented sufficiently this time.
Great news from Latin America:
The first edition of the UA-Magazine in Spanish has been released by our colleagues in Quito, Ecuador!
Looking forward to hearing from you.
The Editor.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
Formal recognition and integration of urban agriculture into urban planning and city development has hardly been changed despite an increase in presence and attention. Some countries have witnessed a reduction in prohibitive or anti-urban agriculture interventions, but the transformation of city responses from prohibitive models towards permissive or enabling ones has hardly materialised nor been formalised. The perceptions and responses to urban agriculture among actors in a certain city at any given time are not consistent. It is argued that there is a need for a flexible approach and differential targeting to further stimulate integration.
Planners and policy-makers of Marilao, the Philippines; Accra, Ghana, and Lusaka, Zambia were asked about urban agriculture and planning related issues. Quotations from the interviews are given grouped under questions and issues, related to the issues discussed in the editorial.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
A virtual conference on "Urban and Peri-urban Agriculture on the Policy Agenda" was jointly organised by FAO and ETC-RUAF, from August 21 - September 30, 2000. The conference was divided into three main themes: Household Food Security & Nutrition; Health & Environment; and Urban Planning. This short article revisits some issues regarding the nature of planning, the diverse opportunities for intervention and potential enhancement tools of urban and peri-urban agriculture.
The introductory and final papers, and the discussion of the e-conference can be found here (in English).
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
This article is a synthesis of insights from a short period of participation in a comprehensive urban planning project in Kimberley and Port Elizabeth (South Africa) in 1998 and 1999. It has been observed that the phenomenon of urban agriculture in these two cities challenges the western concepts of urban planning and reinforces the need for new models appropriate to non-industrialised cities of Africa and other developing countries. The western model assumes labour employment for the majority, travel to work and the separation of work, employment, recreation and so on. However, drawing in particular from Port Elizabeth, the South African experience is that a majority of urban inhabitants is unemployed, and the informal sector economy dominates. This means that work, recreation and housing all occur in one place. Urban agriculture is one activity in the informal sector.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
This paper presents the findings from a UK Government Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) funded survey examining the role played by planning in regulating urban agriculture on allotments, community gardens and city farms in metropolitan areas of the UK. Planners' attitudes to, and knowledge of, urban food production are explored; the geography of, and the agencies involved in, urban food production is detailed and an examination of the regulation of urban food production is undertaken. Despite encouraging signs of an increasing engagement with urban agriculture, planning's apparent low level of involvement remains perplexing given the significance of food to the metropolitan system.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
In Russia, agricultural activities of the urban inhabitants are taking place at significant distances from their urban homes. The term "urban agriculture" refers more to agricultural activities of city dwellers than to agricultural activities within the city boundaries only. The agricultural sites, usually with a house, are called dachas and are located between 6 and 60 km from the city. This article call for the necessary inputs by NGO's and farmer organisations to improve technical know-how and improved use of the facilitating infrastructure to urban agriculture in St. Petersburg.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
Current urban planning and development in Bulgaria does not take into account the existence of urban and peri-urban agriculture. The SWAPUA project, operating in 10 cities in five CEE countries, has identified characteristics of the various types of farming and the main problems associated with urban and peri-urban farming, with an emphasis on soil and water management issues. Here, the case study of the Bulgarian city Trojan is presented.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
The growth and geographical spread of urban agriculture in Zimbabwe is largely attributed to the harsh effects of economic structural adjustment programmes (ESAP). The land under cultivation has also increased under the economic hardships of the last years. The responsiveness and actions of urban local authorities in addressing the pressing needs of the urban community has become of utmost significance. The mandate of the Women and Land Lobby Group is to advocate and lobby for gender-sensitive land policies and promote women's economic empowerment through the equitable access to and control of land. The organisation is concerned with ensuring that policies affecting women's access to land are effectively translated into practice and implementation.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
In 1987, Sanyal suggested that Lusaka, Zambia, was the capital city of urban agriculture (UA) in Africa. This was at the peak of Zambia's economic crisis. Today, one will easily agree that Harare, Zimbabwe, has taken over as the capital of urban agriculture. There is no longer abundant maize growing and in addition, there is little integration into planning. In fact, urban and peri-urban agriculture has been marginalised out of planning; it is not considered a priority by the city authorities and is being gradually squeezed out by residents seeking lodgings to rent, as well as developers. Under these circumstances, a recurring question is 'what factors determine the integration (or otherwise) of urban agriculture into city planning'?
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
In the present form, agricultural activities in the city of Dar Es Salaam often conflict with planning of urban land-uses. In some cases, agricultural activities are conducted in fragile environments or hazardous areas of the city, resulting in land degradation and water pollution. In other cases the activities are carried out in areas affected by industrial pollution. The initiative by the Dar Es Salaam City Council to adopt the Environmental Planning and Management approach in the city planning in 1992, was timely and most welcome. Achievements accrued from the new approach have provided significant change to the common practices.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
Today, the scale of urban agriculture (UA) in Botswana's urban settlements is very limited comparing to the intensive agricultural practices found in other Southern African cities. In the capital of Gaborone, one of the fastest growing cities in Africa, a few agricultural projects have been started and integrated into its urban development. The aim of this article is to give more details on these improvements using a case study of Glen Valley that is a typical example of urban agriculture integration into urban planning.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
Traditionally, municipalities in Nepal are defined on the basis of (the accumulation of) non-farm activities. Agriculture is considered to be a rural activity, which is one constraint to the promotion of urban agriculture. How this problem was overcome is narrated in this article, which describes the integration of urban agriculture into the land-use planning of Madhyapur Thimi municipality located in the centre of Kathmandu Valley in Nepal.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
Scaling up of activities requires land-use planning municipal policies, as well as specific technical, financial and legal incentives, laws or regulations related to land tenure, access and land taxation. The municipality of Santiago de los Caballeros, in the Dominican Republic, aims to promote a more coherent and effective inclusion of urban agriculture citywide through municipal management and land-use planning policies, mechanisms and instruments.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
The Municipality of Quito is challenged by demands to eradicate urban poverty, to improve the urban environment and to promote a participatory style of governance. Urban agriculture is a potential source of food, income and employment, and is part of a multifunctional use of land, and therefore has an important and strategic role to play in this development. By way of a participatory city consultation on urban agriculture, the municipality embarked upon a process of institutionalising urban agriculture.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
Politicians and planners are faced with many competing claims for the use of scarce land in and around cities in industrialised countries. Multifunctional land use - combining different functions within one area - offers a solution. On the basis of a case study in the heavily populated west of the Netherlands, the authors aim to demonstrate that urban agriculture can be promoted as one element land-use offering valuable functions to society.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
An examination of suburban development plans and official plan documents revealed that planning for urban agriculture in suburban development planning is non-existent in North American cities. While proponents of urban agriculture seek land for food production on remnants and left-over spaces in the core, built up areas of cities, they ignore the potential to include spaces for urban food production in the settlements of the future, from the outset.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
Agriculture is an old urban function. It never ceased to exist in developing countries and is now once again welcome in most developed countries as well. Poor Brazilian communities see urban agriculture as an alternative survival strategy, because it produces food and improves household's nutrition, but also generates income and jobs. In Portugal, city gardening is small-scale, aimed at giving opportunities for child and adult education, providing ways to produce and consume healthy food, and to enhance contact with land and living things.
In: UA Magazine 4 - Integration of UPA in urban planning
Marilao, located on the fringe of Manila in the Philippines, faced a typical peri-urban dilemma a few years ago, when its mayor could not find affordable land for a new waste disposal site. There were more than 850 business firms and housing projects that competed for the use of municipal land. Not only the problem of where to bring the waste was a problem, also what to do with recycled waste and changes in policy and urban management needed to be tackled.
The UA-Magazine is published by the Resource Centre for Urban Agriculture (RUAF), a Programme executed by ETC Netherlands and financed by DGIS, The Netherlands and IDRC, Canada. It is published 3 times a year. The UA Magazine is translated into French and Spanish, and distributed in separate editions through regional networks.
This issue has been compiled by René van Veenhuizen (Responsible Editor), together with Beacon Mbiba (Guest Editor). Valuable inputs have been received by Axel Drescher.
![]()
Agricultural activities within the city limits have existed since the first urban populations were established thousands of years ago. Yet only recently has urban agriculture become a systematic focus of research and development attention as its scale and importance in the urbanising world we live in become increasingly recognised. Urban agriculture has been recognised as a cross-sectoral issue that requires a multi-sectoral and multi-actor approach and active participation of the direct and indirect stakeholders in the planning and implementation of policies and action programmes. This requires the adaptation of the methods used in rural agricultural research and development for the specific urban conditions and to realise an innovative integration of these methods with the methods applied by urban managers and planners and other relevant disciplines.
This issue of the Urban Agriculture Magazine contains the synthesis papers produced by the six topic co-ordinators and selected contributions submitted to the editor and written for the expert workshop "Appropriate Methodologies for Urban Agriculture".
Great news from West Africa this time: the first edition of the UA-Magazine in French has been released by our colleagues of IAGU in Dakar, Senegal. French readers are suggested to contact IAGU. Issue no. 2 on Livestock is now available in Spanish. Please contact UMP-LAC.
You are invited to contribute to future issues of the Urban Agriculture Magazine. Articles would ideally be up to 2,500 words in length, and preferably accompanied by illustrations (digital and of good quality), references and an abstract. As suggested by the Editorial Board, we welcome your contributions on any subject. Articles will be examined for selection by the editorial team consisting of the RUAF-based responsible editor and the external scientific advisor/co-editor.
Looking forward to hearing from you.
The Editor
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Agricultural activities within the city limits have existed since the first urban populations were established thousands of years ago. Yet only recently has urban agriculture become a systematic focus of research and development attention as its scale and importance in the urbanising world we live in become increasingly recognised.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Developments in urban agriculture have been practitioner-led. Researchers are trying to catch up and identify what contributions they can make. Research could learn from the successes and failures addressed in other forms of agriculture, and thus identify and address the researchable questions in a proactive way. Those who wish to engage in the development of agriculture in cities will need to take a constructivist approach to innovation facilitation, whereby they should recognise that they are just one of a set of actors involved in the process.Here, the authors review some methods that have been used in the study of urban agriculture, from actor-oriented and action-research perspectives.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
The incorporation of gender considerations into urban agriculture research is increasing, and indeed, there have been advances over the last decade in our understanding of both men's and women's experiences with farming in cities around the world. There is a move away from the so-called "urban farmer", an undifferentiated, masculine, normalised urban dweller who engages in agriculture. Instead, there is greater recognition that people's experiences with urban agriculture cannot be easily standardised and that gender neutrality does not necessarily capture the breadth of such experiences.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Situation analysis in urban and peri-urban agriculture is often a starting point for programmes and projects supporting interventions to improve the contribution of urban agriculture to income, family nutrition, social and environmental conditions and well-being. Yet there has been little specific consideration of appropriate methods and tools for assisting situation analysis in the urban and periurban context. The focus in this article is on methods, which help to build and facilitate action-oriented programmes, particularly emphasising participatory diagnosis and learning. We consider some of the broader analytical frameworks for understanding, and the conceptual challenges in investigating UPA. We then discuss some specific contexts of investigation in a UPA setting and raise issues for critical reflection in relation to the use of the methods and tools described.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
The local government of Montevideo, along with its citizens and civil organisations, is promoting baseline studies and action plans for the implementation of urban agriculture programmes. Baseline studies should identify the principal practices and their distribution in the city. The fieldwork allows for comprehension of the most relevant characteristics of the urban farmers, as well as experiences of public organisations (Municipality of Montevideo, schools, universities, etc.), NGOs, and producer organisations. In addition, it examines the nutritional state and the current normative and legal framework of the city.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
For market-oriented farmers, the agriculture production plan should be derived from a proper marketing plan, not vice versa. The issue for farmers is not which crops can be grown, since this may be many, but what can be profitably sold. However, sound market development and advice, is a more difficult task than transferring production skills. This is the reason why market extension is often lacking or not a priority. This paper describes an Urban and Peri-urban Agriculture Rapid Appraisal (UPARA) for the assessment of social, economic, and technical factors affecting market gardeners. For market-oriented farmers, the agriculture production plan should be derived from a proper marketing plan, not vice versa. The issue for farmers is not which crops can be grown, since this may be many, but what can be profitably sold. However, sound market development and advice, is a more difficult task than transferring production skills. This is the reason why market extension is often lacking or not a priority.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Urban agriculture research in Southern and Eastern Africa has concentrated largely on the use of questionnaires and surveys, usually with a view to understanding the economic benefits accruing to those who practice urban agriculture. For researchers, the focus has been on identifying and analysing the contribution of urban agriculture to income generation, subsistence and food security or on considering its environmental and planning implications. So what are the dynamics behind urban agricultural activity in this context? Why do people living in low-income settlements in Cape Town invest time and money in agriculture in the absence of economic benefits?
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Urban agriculture is not a new phenomenon in the present-day cities of the world, and is more and more considered as an integrated part of urban management (as a strategy for poverty alleviation, income and employment generation and environmental management). However, only in few cases has urban agriculture been integrated into policy-making and planning.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
The scope and popular recognition of the social revolution that began in Cuba in 1959 has created a Cuban model of participation in which the people identify with, and make theirs, the claims of the government. As a result the population is very involved in carrying out projects, but is much less involved in planning processes. Community participation in planning for urban agriculture development in Cuba is directly related to this particular model of participation.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
This paper introduces a methodology for assessing the social and economic policy implications of pollution impacts on the yield, quality and safety of urban and peri-urban crops. The approach emphasises non-market valuation of agricultural produce and the inclusion of the poor, whilst developing strategies to link the micro- and macro-level policy perspectives to influence ongoing policy debates.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Despite increasing attention, little is known about the actual extent and spatial distribution of urban agriculture in inner city areas. Questions need to be answered about the concentration of urban agricultural activities and the reasons for this concentration, kinds of soils occupied, water availability and quality, crops grown, (groups of) actors involved, distance to markets, and the contribution of the product to urban food security and nutrition. The application of any tool requires community participation.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Urban agriculture cannot be perceived, assessed, or developed as if it exists or has existed in a historical or political vacuum. Power relations and non-material processes have shaped urban environments for centuries. Attention to these issues is important, when considering the need and desirability for more urban agriculture development in cities. This article first discusses the relevance of a political ecology of urban agriculture; it highlights the importance of an actor-oriented approach in understanding the link between urban planning and urban agriculture. Secondly, it will refer to Mexico City's actors' interplay in the context of a local and global politicised environment.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
The City of Malaybalay in Bukidnon Province in the Southern Philippines has areas lying within the Pantaron - a very critical mountain range for securing water resources for Mindanao Island. Belgian and Philippine research institutes have joined continuing efforts to facilitate the official recognition, by local government units and national line agencies, of the inherent capability of indigenous communities to ensure a sustainable environment using a GIS methodology. A pilot area has been set up in the city for promoting participatory environmental management with a solid scientific basis. This article describes the background and principles of the approach.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
The urban agriculture production system is characterised by a variety of agricultural micro-enterprises, the performance of which is not only limited by bio-climatic, land and socio-economic constraints but also by important technical restrictions. Although urban farmers are quite dynamic and innovative and have a vast scope for technical improvement, the rate of development and diffusion of technologies to these systems is still limited. This article explores the methods and procedures that may be applied with success to urban agriculture.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
This article presents a social analysis of the co-ordination of the production-consumption chain in agriculture. The inter-relations in two production-consumption chains are compared; cereals and dairy in Senegal. Social network analysis is a valuable means of exploring the dynamics of urban agriculture and how economic reasoning is embedded in these social networks.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Farmers in urban settings sometimes have limited pools of local technical knowledge on which to draw compared to their rural counterparts, sometimes because they are new to farming, sometimes because the environment in which they farm is new and unfamiliar. The Farmer Field Schools (FFS) provides the means for farmers and facilitators to explore available local knowledge and very importantly in this context, to identify the knowledge gaps that need to be addressed. Some pros and cons are discussed below.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Periurban agriculture is confronted with several interrelated issues, which are all linked to increasing population and rapid urban growth. A major concern is the increasing conversion of agricultural land for housing development vis à vis the need to produce sufficient food on a sustainable basis to satisfy the increasing urban demand. This paper presents a case study in which various participatory methods were used in research priority setting and planning, accommodating local knowledge in the development and choice of appropriate technologies and monitoring and evaluation. It will focus on SWAP, which elsewhere is referred to as SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats).
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
The terms Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) are often used in a broader sense than what is known from project work. Half of the resource papers for the workshop presented 'M&E experiences' that consisted of surveys and analyses of biophysical, socio-economic or institutional urban agricultural issues without specific reference to any project or policy intervention. In the strict sense, this kind of "M&E" would be better classified as Situation Analysis and Diagnosis (see the NRI paper). Nonetheless, this topic paper considers that repeated situation analyses also contribute to project M&E. While there is already a well-established body of general literature on M&E in agricultural research and development (R&D), most of the reported experiences are based on the rural setting. Here differences and appropriate methodsare discussed.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
In Tanzania, urban and peri-urban agriculture is a well-known activity and has reached the level of official acceptance (Jacobi et al. 2000). Systematic monitoring and evaluation as well as channelling generated information and feedback from the field to the relevant levels has supported this acceptance. A balance is sought between "conventional" and "participatory" monitoring. Both "hard data" are necessary, as is a system that allows primary stakeholders to monitor and evaluate their activities using different methods and their own indicators. Truly appropriate monitoring and evaluation should enhance internal learning and provide evidence to support qualitative statements about the impact of an action. This information can be relevant to members of the community and to decision-makers.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Malnutrition is a serious public health problem in Bangladesh. It can have serious impacts on the population as it retards child growth, increases the risk and duration of illness, reduces work output, and slows social and mental development. Improving nutritional status, including micronutrient status, can lead to increased productivity, increased child survival and growth, and reduced maternal morbidity and mortality.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
This paper provides practical indicators and field methods for assessing the impact of urban and periurban agriculture in social and economic terms (employment, income, added value, and food supply). In a context of growing advocacy for policy support in favour of urban agriculture, and while public resources are shrinking, it is necessary that researchers provide rigorous assessments of the contribution of agriculture to the city's policy objectives (Ellis and Sumberg 1998). This paper is based on the author's fieldwork in West and Central Africa, with a focus on vegetable production and marketing (Moustier 2000), as well as on a literature review.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Despite widely known benefits, urban agriculture is often marginalised in urban planning, considered a temporary activity and inconsistent with the idea of a modern city. It occupies space where, it is argued, more economically valuable development could take place. This last argument is probably valid if the market value of the output of UA is compared to, say, a commercial development. But, it is less clear cut if we include the non-market benefits of UA. This inclusion of non-market benefits is the basis of a form of cost-benefit analysis that has emerged in the past decade. While measuring the monetary value of market goods is relatively straightforward, valuing non-market benefits is more of a challenge.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Much of the developing countries' rapidly growing population, forms part of the economy that lies outside the regulatory framework of governments, in what is known as the informal sector. Although the definitions vary according to the country context, it is generally agreed that the informal sector, whether rural or urban, comprises small and micro-enterprises producing and distributing basic goods and services in unregulated, but competitive markets. Micro-enterprises provide income and employment for significant proportions of workers in rural and urban areas.
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
The PROVE - "Small Agricultural Production Verticalisation Programme", is a programme designed to promote small agricultural production, processing and trade. It involves many urban and peri-urban agricultural systems, including vegetable-gardening, fruit-growing and livestock systems. Intervention is at the individual and/or collective level, especially aimed at the lower income groups. The stages of the approach are given in (eleven) rungs in a ladder
In: UA Magazine 5 - Methodologies for UA research, policy development, planning and implementation
Two studies were conducted to characterise the demand of private households, vendors and institutional users for fresh vegetables in Cagayan de Oro City, the Philippines. Specifically, these surveys aimed to provide baseline data for decision-makers and farmer-practitioners to further improve the market transparency for vegetables and, thus, contribute to better producer and consumer linkages.
The UA Magazine is published by the Resource Centre for Urban Agriculture (RUAF), a Programme co-ordinated by ETC Netherlands and financed by DGIS, the Netherlands, and IDRC, Canada. The UA Magazine is published 3 times a year, and is translated into French and Spanish, and distributed in separate editions through regional networks.
This issue has been compiled by René van Veenhuizen (responsible editor), together with the topic coordinators.
Ecological agriculture is seen as especially relevant to the urban setting. The introduction in rural settings of ecological practices is still debated, although it seems that the call for the coexistence of both conventional and ecological farming in an adequate mix seems to be the best option. This begs the question of whether similar arguments apply to the urban setting and which lessons can be learned for urban agriculture.
Ideas on ecological agriculture differ and various concepts exist. Its simplest definition is understood as an agricultural system that is based on ecological principles and applying ecological practices to maintain soil fertility, to manage crop and animal health, and to keep soil and water in a good condition. Others may give the simple explanation of it being agriculture without the use of chemical inputs (e.g., synthetic fertilisers, pesticides and herbicides, or hormones). Yet others see it as much more than that and, for instance, understand it as a vision on healthy products and as a way of life.
The discussion in this issue is not just about definitions, but focuses on the process of "ecologising" urban agriculture and its relevance for sustainable urban development.
The second edition of the UA-Magazine in French has been released by our colleagues of IAGU in Dakar, Senegal. French readers are suggested to contacted IAGU. The fourth issue on Integrating Urban Agriculture in City Planning is also available in Spanish. Please contact UMP-LAC.
You are invited to contribute to future issues of the Urban Agriculture Magazine. Articles would ideally be up to 2,500 words in length, and preferably accompanied by illustrations (digital and of good quality), references and an abstract. As suggested by the Editorial Board, we welcome your contributions on any subject. Articles will be examined for selection by the editorial team consisting of the RUAF-based responsible editor and the external scientific advisor/co-editor.
Looking forward to hearing from you.
The Editor
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
Ecological agriculture is seen as especially relevant to the urban setting. The introduction in rural settings of ecological practices is still debated, although it seems that the call for the coexistence of both conventional and ecological farming in an adequate mix seems to be the best option. This begs the question of whether similar arguments apply to the urban setting and which lessons can be learned for urban agriculture.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
There are several judgements about "Organic Production": it is typically an invention of the rich in Western Europe, projecting their loss in nature and biodiversity onto developing countries." or "organic production as a notion has too many definitions: What is the difference between organic, biological, ecological, biodynamic, integrated or agroecological production?" or yet again "it is too complicated for poor people to quickly understand," Scientists and policy-makers however, encounter evidence that organic production does make sense. Pretty (1999) shows that organic production provides sufficient and healthy food in developing countries. Developments in Cuba show that organic production raised more advantages than was accepted before. Evidence from Western Europe demonstrates that organic production is profitable indeed. However, it is still problematic to understand exactly what falls under the notion "organic production". One thing is clear: organic production has strong potential for drawing consumer response. This article explains the discrepancy between judgement and reality concerning organic production.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
Over the years the poor have migrated to the cities in Latin America and the Caribbean in their search for higher incomes and a better life. Cities in the region have grown rapidly, and for the first time in history there are more poor people living in urban than in rural areas. Among the strategies employed by both the poorer urban population, and the local governments are agriculture and biodiversity conservation. Recent research conducted in Havana (Cuba); Montevideo (Uruguay) and Porto Alegre (Brazil) provide ample examples thereof.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
Cities like Vienna (Austria) are known for great monuments and wonderful art. At first glance, urban agriculture seems to be limited to public baroque gardens, some vineyards, Schrebergärten and intensive vegetable growing. But recently, clever consultants, organic farmers and "green-minded" consumers have developed a new concept of urban organic farming that allows new ways of interaction between organic farmers and urban citizens in residential areas.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
This paper is based on a project proposal to set up urban organic gardens in Thailand. The author takes the Cuban experience as a starting point and gives his ideas on the "transition process".
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
Adapted report of a study to discover the factors which determine the choice of farmers in the UK, Spain and Brazil of agricultural technology and why some adopt sustainable production techniques. Organic farming was chosen as the basis for the empirical analysis used throughout the project.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
Consumers are increasingly calling for safe and healthy food and have more knowledge about this. Once convinced, they are more likely to accept higher prices for such food. Producers should therefore thriving to prove that the quality and safety of their commodities is to consumers' standard. Labelling is a strong tool to do so. But what is labelling? And how to certify that the label does what it promises? Certification is the answer to this.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
The organic approach to food production has long been considered by Ethiopian decision-makers as one which leads to poor yields, is backward and a reason for decaying farming systems. However, the reality is completely different. Recently, urban agriculture is accepted as a new and important frontier to food production and even as a tool to fight poverty and environmental pollution. The bio-intensive approach to urban agriculture is simply to rely more and more on natural processes rather than on external inputs resulting in a simpler, more affordable and local approach, leading to greater equity, replicability and sustainability. This article is aimed at sharing the author's long years of experience in Ethiopia in the effort to promote urban agriculture.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
The term "permaculture" is derived from Bill Mollison's vision of permanent agriculture. Permaculture is about producing food in an environmentally sound way. It is concerned with people growing their own food on their own land and using it for themselves, their immediate family and possibly the local community. This is the impression gained from examining permaculture food projects in Britain. Since its inception permaculture has developed and diversified. It is essentially an approach to designing productive whole systems, through the maximisation of the interconnectedness of elements, which has an ethical foundation in sustainability and a scientific basis in ecology. The key characteristic is that it sets out to maximise beneficial relationships through the effective placement of elements.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
The Community Patio project in Havana, Cuba, described in this article, encourages the practice of urban agriculture, utilising permaculture techniques in small spaces in the home (patios, balconies, rooftops, gardens, terraces, etc.) producing food, medicinal plants, spices and ornamental plants. It further includes environmental education and capacity-building for neighbours and other interested parties through periodic workshops, courses and conferences.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
A typical phenomenon of urban agriculture is its specialisation in perishable products. In Kumasi, Ghana, as in other cities in sub-Saharan Africa, vegetable market production takes place on inner-city lowland areas, close to stream and drains or in the periurban environment, where high amounts of seeds, manure/fertiliser and pesticides are used. Research is undertaken into biological production methods and to risks reducing options beyond the farm level, i.e. at markets and households, but it shows that the adoption rate of biological farming methods remained very low among vegetable growers. How to convince urban farmers and consumers?
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
This shortened version of an earlier published version describes the historic background of why organic and urban agriculture were seen as important by the Cuban Government. Large tracts of land were switched from export-oriented cash crops to food crops. Government incentives encouraged unemployed people in large urban centres to move back to work on the land. This created, almost overnight, a new urban gardening culture. Organic agriculture was specifically promoted by the Cuban Organic Agriculture Organisation, which linked government researchers and extension workers.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
This article takes the previous one further. The economic crisis that struck the country made the revitalisation of old initiatives necessary. For instance, the concept of "Conuco"(plot and garden). The urban agriculture initiatives received widespread support by state institutions, scientific, and non-governmental institutions. The challenge for agriculture in the cities Urban Agriculture without Chemicals is described.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
Family agricultural activity growth in the Mexican regions of Xochimilco, Milpa Alta, Tlalpan, Texcoco, Azcapotzalco and Tláhuac has improved the diets of many families, who, due to their depressed economic situation, have few opportunities to buy vegetables (Canabal 2000). Urban agriculture further creates employment and may lead to improvement in the environment when utilising organic inputs and recycling water and waste. The Opciones de Autosuficiencia Familiar (Family Subsistence Alternatives) project working to facilitate the contribution of urban agriculture is described here.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
A major theme in the creation of viable urban-rural interfaces is the creation of natural resource scarcities by urbanisation. Urbanisation is driven by the desire for short-run economic growth and wealth in ever growing cities. Therefore, periurban agriculture should provide a bypass for this ecologically unhealthy development of large urban agglomerations. Sustainable, or at least less ecologically harmful, development of mega-cities can only be reached if it is grounded in a better development of periurban agriculture, biotic resource recycling and waste management.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
South Africa is being pulled into the global economy. Still there is a great need for locally produced food, as is shown in this story about the Cape Flats bio-zone. The Cape Flats townships, low-income settlements to the northeast of Cape Town, are vast encampments at the city gates. While the majority of government agricultural development funds are being poured into the conventional, often large-scale farm movement, the general organic movement is alive and well. Abalimi Bezekhaya (Planters of the Home) is an NGO focusing consistently on direct poverty alleviation through micro-organic vegetable gardening among the poor.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
The promotion of sustainable local livelihoods through urban agriculture will be unsustainable if urban farmers get trapped in the same cycle of dependency on expensive chemical farm inputs, like fertiliser and pesticides. This realisation has led to the promotion of organic urban farming by local community organisations in the cities of Valencia and Malaybalay in Bukidnon province, and Cagayan de Oro city in Mindanao, Philippines.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
Argentina, like the rest of Latin America, is confronted with the challenge of combating structural poverty. Urban agriculture - particularly when using organic methods - is seen as a viable and appropriate strategy for easing poor urban sectors. This article presents two cases in which this strategy was developed in two cities contrasting greatly in size: Rosario and Camilo Aldao.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
According to a study, organic production has increased constantly in the last years in Costa Rica, involving a high diversity of crops. The Organic Farming Program of the University of Costa Rica works in research, extension, and teaching of soils, animals and plants, post harvest management, and rural development. This Programme coordinates all the activities on organic farming at the University and has cooperative links with other institutions both at national and international levels. This article narrates some of the experiences.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
Farmers generally recognize the benefits of organic matter and seek to acquire it. Demand for compost is high, but studies in Africa and India show that farmers have difficulty acquiring enough organic matter at suitable prices. Composting of municipal solid wastes is now being promoted to reduce the amounts of waste requiring disposal and treatment by cities. The potential for improving low-cost reuse of urban waste is discussed here.
In: UA Magazine 6 - Transition to Ecological Urban Agriculture: A Challenge
In the twin city Hubli-Dharwad, untreated sewage is commonly used for irrigation in peri-urban agriculture. Farmers extract sewage for irrigation from sewage nallahs (open sewers) and underground sewer pipes. In this semi-arid climate the waste water is an extremely valuable resource for farmers, as pumping from sewage nallahs or drains is cheaper than a borehole, which makes the practice more accessible to farmers with fewer financial resources. It also provides an irrigation source during the dry season, when farmers can sell their produce for three to five times the kharif (monsoon) season prices. However, Unregulated and continuous irrigation with sewage may lead to environmental problems and poses serious public health risks. The adoption of certain micro technologies can reduce the risks faced by farmers who have irrigated with sewage.
The UA Magazine is published by the Resource Centre for Urban Agriculture (RUAF), a Programme co-ordinated by ETC Netherlands and financed by DGIS, the Netherlands, and IDRC, Canada. The UA Magazine is published 3 times a year, and is translated into French, Spanish, Arabic and Chinese, and distributed in separate editions through regional networks.
This issue has been compiled by René van Veenhuizen (responsible editor), together with Moniek van Hintum
Guesteditors: Eric Goewie, The Netherlands; Yilma Getachew, Ethiopia and The Spanish Edition Editorial Group consists of: Vilda Figueroa, Cuba; Patricio Yañes, Chile; Mario Gonzalez Novo, Cuba; Alain Santandreu, Uruguay.
June and July have been very productive for RUAF, especially for the Magazine. Aside from the development of this issue, no. 7, on the Ecomomics of Urban Agriculture, we have had the Electronic Conference on "Agricultural Use of Untreated Urban Wastewater in Low Income Countries", which will be the topic for the next issue of the UA-Magazine (no.8) and two special issues of the UA-Magazine have also been published. The first one, Urban Agriculture and Food Security, was distributed at the FAO World Summit on Food Security, held in June in Rome, Italy. The second, has been prepared for the World Summit on Sustainable Development, which will be held in Johannesburg, South Africa, in August 2002. Both specials can be downloaded as PDF at the bottom of this page.
Urban agriculture provides multiple functions and benefits to urban dwellers and cities. Political support is growing but further research and financial support to urban agriculture is necessary. In this issue no. 7of the UA Magazine we focus on the analysis and understanding of the economics of urban agriculture, during periods of economic recession as well as in times of a well developing economy. The Economics of Urban Agriculture is a wide area of study. Various case studies are presented in this issue analysing factors as employment, income, contribution to household food and support in access to markets and credit, both at household and/or municipal level. Investment in and support to urban agriculture is touched upon in quite a number of articles. This important issue will be elaborated upon in the UA-Magazine no. 9, to be presented to you in March 2003.
Further good news is that the RUAF partners are now complete and that thus, the editions of the UA-Magazine in Chinese and Arabic are about to be released by our colleagues of CEDARE in Cairo, Egypt and IGSNRR in China. Readers in those languages are suggested to contact these institutes. The Spanish and French editions of the UA-Magazine have both now published no. 4 on Urban Planning.
You are invited to contribute to future issues of the Urban Agriculture Magazine. Articles would ideally be up to 2,500 words in length, and preferably accompanied by illustrations (digital and of good quality), references and an abstract. As suggested by the Editorial Board, we welcome your contributions on any subject. Articles will be examined for selection by the editorial team consisting of the RUAF-based responsible editor and the external scientific advisor/co-editor.
Looking forward to hearing from you.
The Editor
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Urban agriculture provides multiple functions and benefits to urban dwellers and cities. Political support is growing and further research and financial support to enhance the contribution of urban agriculture to sustainable urban development is necessary. In this issue of the UA Magazine we focus on the analysis and understanding of the economics of urban agriculture, during periods of economic recession as well as in times of a well developing economy.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Urban Agriculture has been recognised in many cities to be a vehicle for urban environmental improvement, and for strengthening the development of productive, sustainable and democratic cities. Both financial and political legitimacy are essential to support this development and the scaling-up of positive experiences. Progress has been recorded and assessed on political support rather than on the financial one, despite a growing interest of development and financial agencies.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Market proximity is a major incentive for the intensification of farming systems or change of systems to more profitable ones. Around Kumasi, many rainfed maize-cassava farmers started dry-season vegetable production along streams to generate additional income, while in the city itself, year-round open-space vegetable production is common, especially in bottomlands with water access for irrigation. The motivation to start urban vegetable farming is largely economic, which is the subject of this article.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
The horticultural and ornamental plant production sector of the district of Moreno in Buenos Aires, Argentina, is strategically located in an urban area with direct access to the major markets of the country. Horticultural producers predominantly belong to the Bolivian colony, with scarce income, using own labour, living in extremely substandard housing. They have recently established a Local Commercialisation Market with the institutional support of the Moreno Municipal Institute of Local Economic Development (IMDEL). Growers of ornamental plants are mostly from the Japanese (herbs) and Italian (trees and shrubs) communities, who are capable of undertaking larger capital investments in their operations. They have established a local association and in 2001 organised the first Exhibit of Plants and Cut Flowers of Moreno. Both groups of producers have benefited from the National Employment Emergency Plan. IMDEL offered the producers micro-credits at low rates. The experiences are described here.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Conjunto Palmeira is a slum with 30,000 inhabitants, situated in the southern area of Fortaleza-Cearà , a metropolis located in the northeast of Brazil. The first inhabitants arrived here in 1973 and started building their houses spontaneously, without access to purified water, electric power, schools or other public services. In 1981, the Association of Settlers of the Conjunto Palmeira (ASMOCONP) was founded, starting the process of organisation of the families. Banco Palmas has opened a small line of credit for urban agriculture, which is described here.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Urban agriculture can provide benefits but also risks for urban inhabitants. This study confirmed that the strengths overshadow the risks of practicing home gardening in a sub-Sahelian setting, and underlined the positive economic impact and food security for home gardeners. However, these two benefits depend on seasonal variations and external factors. Nevertheless, home gardeners still have a precarious existence and need strategies for increasing their security. This article is based on a study of the socio-economic impact of home gardening in the capital of Burkina Faso, Ouagadougou (Gerstl 2001). Among other aspects, this study examined home gardening as a livelihood compared to other livelihood activities carried out by people with a similar background, both in terms of amount of income and in the way it varied from season to season and from place to place. The reasons for this variation were investigated, in order to make suggestions on how the situation for these families could be improved.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
A study was carried out in order to assess the economic performance of the periurban agroecosystem known as "chinampa". Chinampa is small piece of land of irregular form, of pre-Hispanic origin, where inhabitants from the valley of Mexico still produced a diversity of plants for the city. These were built in a lacustrine setting by reclaiming land bordering a lake and building the plots and a network of channels. Results showed a different use of inputs in the four chinampa plots studied and different economic performances, although all were positive. Farmers with lower use of external inputs (seeds and fertilisers) were less productive in terms of yields but obtained better returns per each dollar invested. This shows the importance of the use of local resources and its positive impact on the economies of small-scale farmers in a periurban setting.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Unlike in rural Kenya where agricultural promotion is an integral part of development initiatives, agriculture is excluded from formal urban land-use systems. However, urban agriculture constitutes a critical food security strategy for low income urban farming families. Also, urban agriculture is an important aspect of urban agribusiness where the sector generates important income and employment opportunities. Urban agriculture lacks access to efficient credit and investment support services. The agro-based industries are playing an important role in the promotion of urban agriculture, which can be enhanced by an organised farmers' society and favourable government policy environment. This paper covers two case studies of farmer-industry linkages in the capital city of Nairobi.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
The question raised in the title has been answered on paper by the Southside Chamber of Commerce in the city of Brisbane, in sub-tropical Australia. The chamber calculated that a "rooftop microfarm" based on waste management could yield around 20% return on invested capital, and employ three to four people. The Southside Chamber of Commerce Urban Agriculture Group is now considering how to fund a pilot project in Mt Gravatt Central in Brisbane, in the state of Queensland to prove the feasibility study findings. The project is described here.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Urban agriculture emerged in Cuba, specifically Havana, from the economic crisis of 1989, as a response to food insecurity, and has become one of the largest sources of employment in Havana. The existance of agriculture in the city has influenced the prices of agricultural products in Havana.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
One principal factor for the slow development of the urban and peri-urban agricultural sector in Zimbabwe is the inadequate, or in some cases total absence of financing arrangements, especially from the formal sector. This article draws on the experiences of two schemes in Harare - Musikavanhu Project and the Kintyre Lake Country (KLC) Development. The former is a fairly well established co-operative scheme for the urban resource-poor that has been in existence since 1998 while the latter is a land development scheme implemented by the private sector since 1999. The two provide useful information on which to evaluate the prospects for financing urban and periurban agriculture for the different income groups.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
In many low income countries, municipalities often lack necessary physical, financial, institutional and regulatory means to safely dispose of wastewater. On the other hand, farmers in urban and periurban areas find wastewater to be a valuable resource to grow high value crops. Wastewater becomes especially precious for farmers in water scarce situations. Unless effective regulatory mechanisms are enforced, the users of wastewater tend to ignore social costs as long as the private gains from wastewater agriculture exceed private costs. This paper presents data from a case study from Pakistan's southern Punjab, and estimates private and social gains from wastewater agriculture and compares these to the freshwater agriculture. The paper argues that by adopting more farmer-inclusive approaches to wastewater disposal by the planners, both the private and social gains could be maximised.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Among the approximately two million residents of the Metropolitan District of Quito, Ecuador, 45% live in conditions of poverty, and 12% in destitution. These conditions are linked to and aggravated by the economic crisis produced by the structural adjustment policies of the last three years. The "AGRUPAR" Programme, described here, aims to combat the disproportionate impact of the economic crisis on the poorest urban populations, focusing on the generation of income and employment and ecological protection of natural resources.
In: UA Magazine 7 - Economic Aspects of Urban Agriculture
Studies calculating the contribution of urban agriculture to income are unlikely to accurately estimate the quantities of food produced because informal agricultural activities are not generally included. This paper explores some of the current issues and economic aspects of urban and periurban agriculture in East London. Since a formal analysis of the economic costs and benefits is beyond the bounds of this paper, it is intended to lead to discussion of the need to support a re-development of a sustainable, food economy in East London, support for sustainable, social enterprises, and a rethink of our cities' relationship to food.
The UA Magazine is published by the Resource Centre for Urban Agriculture (RUAF), a Programme co-ordinated by ETC Netherlands and financed by DGIS, the Netherlands, and IDRC, Canada. The UA Magazine is published 3 times a year, and is translated into French and Spanish, and distributed in separate editions through regional networks.
This issue has been compiled by René van Veenhuizen (responsible editor), together with César Caramillo Avila of the Municipality of Quito (as Guest editor), and with the RUAF partners.